Metal Roofing Pros and Cons: Is a Metal Roof Right for You?

If you’re contemplating a new roof for your home or business, you’ve likely started the cost-benefit analysis of major roofing systems. A metal roof is a significant investment, and the big question is: Is it worth it?

To help you with your decision, we’ve compiled a quick list of the top 3 benefits and the top 3 drawbacks of metal roofing, focusing specifically on a standing seam metal roof system.

—–Top 3 Benefits of Metal Roofing

1. Exceptional Longevity and Life Span

A properly installed standing seam metal roof is one of the longest-lasting roofing options on the market. Unlike asphalt shingles that degrade over time, metal roofs are built to endure. The minimum expected life span for a high-quality metal roof is 40 years, and it’s very common for them to last 80 years or more, depending on the material specifications and quality of installation.

2. Lowest Long-Term Cost (True Value)

While the upfront cost is higher, a metal roof is actually one of the most cost-effective roofs over its total lifespan. In the time one metal roof lasts, a property often requires 2 to 3 replacements of a traditional shingle roof.

For example:

• Metal Roof: Costs $50,000 and lasts 50 years. Annual Cost: $1,000
• Shingle Roof: First roof costs $20,000 (lasts 25 years). Second roof costs $35,000 (due to inflation). Total 50-Year Cost: $55,000 – Annual Cost: $1,100

The metal roof offers superior value and protection with a lower cost per year.

3. Low Maintenance and High Durability

The robust design and strength of a standing seam metal roof mean very little maintenance is required, and the system has a low risk for damage. Hazards like falling tree branches and hail, pose minimal threat. The only required maintenance is typically clearing off debris (like leaves) that might accumulate in valleys or behind penetrations like skylights. An optional investment after 30-40 years is repainting, which can refresh the aesthetic and add another layer of protection against long-term corrosion.

—–Top 3 Drawbacks of Metal Roofing

1. The High Upfront Investment

We’ve established that metal roofing has the lowest long-term cost, but it also demands the largest investment on day one. A genuine standing seam metal roof typically costs 1.5 to 2.5 times more than a quality shingle roof. This initial price point can be a barrier for many consumers. The good news is that we offer flexible financing options that can extend up to 10 years, making the investment affordable on a manageable monthly basis.

2. Sound and Acoustics

Metal roofs are not inherently louder than shingle roofs, but the sound of rain, hail, and other objects creates a distinct ringing pitch that some homeowners find bothersome. This is especially noticeable during heavy rainfall or if your property has trees that drop pine cones or acorns onto the roof surface. While these sounds do not indicate damage, it is a common point of discussion among new metal roof owners.

3. Difficult and Expensive Repairs

Despite their extreme durability, repairs can occasionally be necessary due to storm damage, severe accidents, or home renovations. Repairing a metal roof can be complicated, often requiring the removal and reinstallation of entire panels. This frequently leads to the replacement of the panels themselves. When replacing older panels, a color mismatch is a common issue because the original finish will have faded or weathered over 10+ years of UV exposure. It is often necessary to repaint the entire roof (especially on systems 10-30 years old) to ensure a uniform color. Furthermore, fewer contractors are certified and experienced enough to perform specialized metal roofing repairs, which can make getting the work done a difficult task.

—-Final Verdict

Ultimately, metal roofing is an excellent, long-term solution for many homes and businesses in Metro Detroit. It instantly modernizes the look of a property and provides unparalleled, lasting protection.

The critical factor is partnering with a quality contractor who is certified and highly experienced with the specific metal roofing system they are installing.

If you would like to find out if a metal roof is the right fit for your property, we encourage you to contact our team now. We will inspect your current system, provide an honest evaluation, offer clear pricing and payment options, and then let you make the final, informed decision.

Call our team now at 586-566-0308 or schedule your free inspection online by CLICKING HERE.

I hope this article was helpful, and as always, I hope you have a Kanga-Rific day!

Sincerely,

Bill Burkhardt, Jr.

VP of Marketing & Owner –Four Seasons Kanga Roof